By Duncan Mnisi
A recent (now deleted) episode of the popular South African Open Chats Podcast has sparked intense backlash after hosts made offensive remarks targeting the Coloured community, reigniting nationwide conversations about racism and free speech.
The controversial comments circulated widely on social media, drawing condemnation from citizens, political figures, and advocacy groups alike.
A Facebook user identifying herself as a “Coloured woman” responded powerfully:
“I’m a Coloured woman!! Not broken. Not mad. Not confused. I carry generations in my blood; pain, pride, and power.” Her words struck a chord with many, highlighting the resilience of marginalized communities against persistent stereotypes and discrimination.
Viewers expressed both disappointment and anger. Nicole Dollie commented, “I’m coloured and I agree that it’s hurtful and untrue. I don’t think infringing on people’s freedom of speech is the way to go. Some true, some not.” Her response reflects the ongoing debate about the limits of free expression versus hate speech.
The controversy escalated after clips surfaced where the podcast hosts made disparaging remarks about the Coloured community, including accusations of incest and labeling them “crazy.” In response, Gayton McKenzie, leader of the Patriotic Alliance and South Africa’s Minister of Sports, Arts and Culture, issued a firm statement:
“It’s racism. We’re going after them.” McKenzie condemned the hate speech, emphasizing it undermines social cohesion and will not be tolerated.
The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) also announced it is monitoring the situation, stressing that racist comments have no place in public discourse. Critics argue such remarks perpetuate harmful stereotypes and deepen societal divisions.
Liam Jacobs, a local PA councillor, said, “This clip hurt. Action needs to be taken, and we must make a strong point. We are not your punchline.” Many social media users echoed calls for accountability, with hashtags like #CancelOpenChats trending as people demanded consequences for the hosts.
While some defended the podcast under the banner of free speech, the overwhelming public sentiment called for responsible dialogue and respect. The podcast later issued an apology:
“We acknowledge the hurt caused by the clip and do not support racism or discrimination. We are committed to rectifying our mistake and promoting unity.”
As South Africa continues its journey toward reconciliation and equality, incidents like this serve as a stark reminder of the ongoing struggle to combat hate speech and foster understanding across communities.
